Website Not Generating Leads? How to Find and Fix the Real Problem
Website not generating leads? How to tell a traffic problem from a conversion or follow-up problem, and what to fix first in each case.
By Kenneth7 min read
If your website is not generating leads, the cause is almost always one of three things. Not enough of the right people are visiting, the people who do visit are not taking the next step, or the inquiries that come in are handled too slowly to turn into work. Each problem has a different fix, so work out which one you have before you pay for a redesign or more ads.
You can usually diagnose it with numbers you already have, and the fix for each case is laid out below.
Why is my website not generating leads? Start with three numbers
Before changing anything, pull three numbers for the last 90 days. Rough counts are fine.
- Visitors: how many people came to the site? Google Analytics, your website builder’s dashboard or your hosting provider can tell you.
- Inquiries: how many forms, calls and emails came from the website?
- Customers: how many of those inquiries became paying work?
Put them side by side and the problem usually shows itself.
| What you see | Likely problem | Where to look first |
|---|---|---|
| Very few visitors | Traffic | Search visibility, Google Business Profile, ads |
| Plenty of visitors, few inquiries | Conversion | The offer, cost information, the next step, speed, forms |
| Decent inquiries, few customers | Follow-up | Reply speed, ownership, quotes |
| You cannot answer one of the three | Tracking | Basic tracking, before anything else |
Many owners assume they have a traffic problem, because “more visitors” is the obvious answer. Often the trouble is further down, in conversion or follow-up. Those fixes also tend to be cheaper, so check them honestly before buying more traffic.
Is it a traffic problem?
A traffic problem means not enough of the right people find you, and “the right people” counts as much as the number. Two thousand visitors a month sounds healthy until you notice most of them land on an old blog post, live in another country, or were looking for a job.
Signs you have a traffic problem:
- The site gets a few hundred visitors a month or fewer
- Most visits come from people typing your business name, so only those who already know you
- Search Console shows you appearing for very few searches related to what you sell
What to fix:
- If you serve a local area, start with your Google Business Profile. For many local businesses it brings more calls than the website itself.
- Give each main service its own page, named in the words customers use. “Commercial cleaning for medical offices” gets found. “Our Solutions” does not.
- Set up Search Console, which is free and shows which searches you already appear for. It often turns up pages that are close to ranking and need a little work.
- Use paid search if you need inquiries now while the slower work builds.
Do not fix traffic first if conversion is broken, though. Sending more people to a page that does not convert just makes the same problem more expensive.
Is it a conversion problem?
A conversion problem means people arrive and leave without getting in touch. This is where a lot of small business websites fall down, and it is usually fixable without starting over.
A clear offer above the fold
Picture a visitor on a phone, standing in a parking lot, giving your site a few seconds. The first screen needs to say what you do, who it is for and where you work. “Building better tomorrows together” tells them nothing. “Commercial HVAC repair and maintenance for offices and warehouses across Denver” tells them they are in the right place. Put one button directly underneath.
Answer the cost and process questions
Most visitors arrive wondering roughly how much this will cost, how long it will take, and what happens after they contact you. If the site does not answer that, they go and find a site that does.
You do not need a full price list. A starting price or a typical range, plus a short “how it works” section in three or four steps, removes a lot of the uncertainty that stops people reaching out.
One obvious next step
Look at your homepage and count the things asking for attention: a newsletter popup, a chat bubble, a phone number, a contact button, a brochure download, social icons. With that many things competing, none of them stands out.
Pick one main action for each page, such as “Request a quote” or “Book a call”, and make it the most visible thing on the screen. On phones, make your number tappable as well, because some people would always rather talk.
Mobile speed
Load your own site on your phone over a cellular connection, since office Wi-Fi will flatter it. If you find yourself waiting, so are your visitors. The usual causes are oversized images, sliders, video backgrounds and a pile of tracking and chat scripts nobody remembers adding. Google’s free PageSpeed Insights tool will point at the worst offenders.
Forms that ask the right questions
A form that is too long loses people. One that is too short gives you nothing to work with, so your first reply is a list of questions and the conversation stalls.
Ask for what you need to reply usefully: name, phone or email, what they need, and roughly when. A dropdown for the type of service helps route the inquiry to the right person. Remove anything you never look at.
Then submit your own form. Forms break after a plugin update without anyone noticing more often than you would expect, or they keep sending notifications to someone who left the company a year ago. Make this a monthly habit.
Proof that you are real
Real photos of your team and your work, recent reviews, and specific details such as how long you have been in business all help a stranger trust you. Stock photos of smiling people in headsets do the opposite.
Is it a follow-up problem?
Sometimes the website is doing its job and the work is being lost afterwards.
It is 2:15 on a Tuesday. A form comes in to the info@ inbox, which three people can see. Each of them assumes one of the others will reply. On Thursday someone finally does, and by then the buyer has booked with the company that called back within the hour.
Signs you have a follow-up problem:
- Inquiries come in, but few turn into customers
- Nobody can say who is responsible for replying
- Quotes go out and then nothing happens until the customer chases you
What to fix:
- Send an instant acknowledgment by email or text, telling the person when they will hear from a human
- Give every inquiry one named owner instead of leaving it in a shared inbox
- Get notifications on a phone as well as in a desktop inbox
- Set a target reply time during business hours, and a plan for evenings and weekends
- Follow up after the quote, because quotes with no follow-up often just get forgotten. Our quote follow-up email templates give you wording for each step.
Track where inquiries come from
If you cannot answer “how many inquiries did the website bring last month?”, start here. You cannot tell which fix worked if you never measured the before.
Keep it simple:
- Count form submissions as conversions in your analytics tool
- Add a “How did you hear about us?” dropdown to the form
- Log every inquiry in one place, with its source and its outcome. A Google Sheet is enough to begin with, and a CRM such as HubSpot works if you already have one.
- Once a month, look at which sources produced customers, not just inquiries
Calls are harder to track than forms. At minimum, ask callers how they found you and write it down.
Do you need a new website?
Often, no. Many sites improve noticeably with a clearer headline, cost information, one main button, a shorter form and faster replies, all done on the existing site.
A rebuild makes sense when the site is broken on phones, when nobody on your team can edit it without calling a developer, when it sits on a platform you no longer have access to, or when the business has changed so much that the site describes a company that no longer exists. If you want help working out which category you are in, our marketing and lead generation page explains how we approach it.
A one-afternoon checklist
Set aside an afternoon and work through this list:
- Open the site on your phone, on cellular data. Does it load quickly?
- Show the homepage to someone outside the business for five seconds. Can they say what you do?
- Is there a starting price or a typical range anywhere?
- Does each page have one clear next step?
- Submit your own form. Where did it go, and how long until someone replied?
- Call your own number after hours. What happens?
- Do you know how many inquiries the site brought in last month?
Start with whichever answers you liked least.
The bottom line
A website that is not generating leads usually has a traffic problem, a conversion problem or a follow-up problem, and the three numbers above will tell you which. Fix conversion and follow-up before you pay for more traffic, and set up simple tracking so you can see whether each change worked.
If you would like a second pair of eyes on your website and the process behind it, book a call.
Common questionsFrequently asked.
How do I know if my website has a traffic problem or a conversion problem?
Compare visitors with inquiries over the last few months. Very few visitors points to traffic. Plenty of visitors but almost no forms or calls points to conversion, which means the site is not giving people a reason or an easy way to get in touch.
Do I need a new website to get more leads?
Often not. A clearer headline, price ranges, one obvious next step, a shorter form and faster replies can make a real difference on the site you already have. A rebuild makes sense when the site is broken on phones or nobody on your team can edit it.
Why do inquiries from my website never turn into customers?
Usually because of what happens after the form. Slow replies, a shared inbox nobody owns and no follow-up after a quote all lose work that the website did manage to win.
How long should a contact form be?
Long enough to let you reply usefully, and no longer. Name, contact details, what they need and roughly when is a good start. Drop any field you do not actually use.